The 10 Best Hotels in Put-in-Bay

#1 of 28 hotels in Put-in-Bay

• “Wonderful.”
• “Location is best on the island.”
• “We'll be back!”
• See more reviews of Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel

#2 of 28 hotels in Put-in-Bay

• “Super quiet and incredibly clean.”
• “Walking distance to all the eateries in Put in Bay, and clean, serene atmosphere”
• “great clean room, friendly staff”
• See more reviews of Bodee's Bungalow Adults Only Couples Only Boutique Hotel

#3 of 28 hotels in Put-in-Bay

• “Had a great time.”
• “Nick was super, location was great”
• “Very nice and close to everything!”
• See more reviews of Ahoy Inn Guesthouse

#4 of 28 hotels in Put-in-Bay

• “owners need to do a lot better”
• “Danny and his crew do a wonderful job. the rooms are always clean, as are the linens and pillows!!”
• “We stayed in the studio apartment. We had a good view of the water. The apartment was clean and brig”
• See more reviews of Chapman House

#5 of 28 hotels in Put-in-Bay

• “We overall loved this place and hope to come back next year!”
• “Everything!”
• “Great customer service, friendly staff”
• See more reviews of Bird's Nest Resort

#6 of 28 hotels in Put-in-Bay

• “bugs”
• “Enjoy the sunrises here!!”
• “I loved the units accomodations, the staff and the location.”
• See more reviews of Put-in-Bay Condos

#7 of 28 hotels in Put-in-Bay

• “Clean, close and convenient, affordable price, great communication.”
• “Loved everything!”
• “Great stay!”
• See more reviews of Islander Inn

#8 of 28 hotels in Put-in-Bay

• “Fun , nice , but not worth price increases for holiday”
• “Convenient location to everything ”
• “All in all stay was very pleasant”
• See more reviews of Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center

#9 of 28 hotels in Put-in-Bay

• “Everyone was very nice!”
• “Great location on the lake. Fun to see all the groups coming and going for graduation and wedding.”
• “There was no stay they took $300 dollars from us”
• See more reviews of Bay Lodging Resort

#10 of 28 hotels in Put-in-Bay

• “Overall the stay was good. We celebrated a birthday and had a great time.”
• “Was alright, kinda overpriced for what it was”
• “Great location”
• See more reviews of Island Club Rentals