The desk people didn't have any correct answers. Their places they said to eat were awful or closed. The girl said tomo restaurant was just raw fish but not true. It's Japanese!

The location was great. Liked the atmosphere. Loved the farmers market

Stayed in May 2024

The first room i got had a BUSTED window. On the first floor. Very unsafe. I was able to move rooms with ease, though, thanks to the frontdesk gentleman (nightshift).

Nightshift front desk worker was very kind, attentive, and patient. Rooms were comfortable. It also has a handful of breakfast options which ends at 10 am I believe.

Stayed in April 2024

TV had issues

Clean and comfortable

Stayed in May 2024

Breakfast was basic, coffee was not good and was only lukewarm.

Staff was great.

Stayed in April 2024

Noise from outside

very comfortable room with nice bathroom

Stayed in April 2024

Need more towel racks and a screen on the window. The breakfast should be advertised differently. There were not many options and the oj was sour. It was a lite snack at best.

The shower pressure was awesome!

Stayed in April 2024

Clawfoot tub a huge bonus and it was very clean. It’s also a nicely decorated hotel with a historic vibe.

Stayed in March 2024

The bathroom was a bit snug the shower/bathtub was a bit awkward to get into.

I was nice to be central to the town so we could walk to anything we needed. I thought it was fun to stay in a historical style hotel. They offered a continental breakfast but we didn't have time to try anything.

Stayed in February 2024

Thin walls so neighbor was up early with TV on and it was as though it was on in my room!

Stayed in February 2024

more room

basic breakfast

Stayed in December 2023

People above me on the 3rd floor were loud all throughout the night, which was a bummer

Stayed in December 2023

All the homeless people in front of hotel. And being loud through the late night.

Stayed in December 2023

Noise was reasonable especially after 10p. Easy on/off access to Hwy.

Stayed in November 2023

Bed quite hard, sleeping somewhat difficult. Smallest "queen" bed ever experienced, more like a double bed. Breakfast consisted of dry cereals and coffee/juice; didn't see any other choices. Actual room did not match pictures of room when reviewed for booking, disappointing.

Good location, central Arcata. Easy to walk around.

Stayed in December 2023

I liked everything about it. Was a little sad walking past homeless sitting in building entryways to the left as we arrived and parked, but of course it wasn't a problem and nothing the hotel could have done.

The hotel was restored in the original design, including the furniture - there was even a cute radiator and clawfoot bathtub. It's right on the square in Arcata, which is beautiful and great for the Saturday farmers market. At first I was disappointed that we didn't have a view of the town square, but the side street view was also very nice, with colorful scenery of the hill in the distance, old town shops, and a beautiful tree with red, yellow, and green leaves. The windows opened as well and the bed was comfortable.

Stayed in October 2023

There was not much not to like about the hotel. I t didn't heavy e hair drier I suppose might be one.

I like the cleanliness of the room. The white towels and the continental breakfast starting at 6am. I lke the location of the hotel.

Stayed in November 2023

Nothing

That is an 1915 hotel kept as original as possible

Stayed in November 2023

A noisy car or cars with loud engine seems they were cruising around and you could hear it loud and disturbing my night

Clean room good service excellent location

Stayed in October 2023

Street noise and could hear people talking in rooms nearby

Historical, beautiful building and furnishings, helpful staff

Stayed in November 2023

Noise, though it's an old building so I slept with headphones and it was fine : )

Location, price, delicious sushi dinner

Stayed in October 2023

I am not used to sharing a bathroom.

The room was adequate, clean and comfortable.

Stayed in October 2023

Breakfast was...meh. But unless you're really on a budget, it's worth the extra effort to walk to Los Bagels, Renatas, Big Blue, or Cafe Brio anyway.

Hotel Arcata is a staple in beautiful Arcata. I've stayed there periodically over the years and it's always impressed and been dead reliable. The closure of TJs and the other bar leaves a bit of a hole on that side of the square (and it's been filled by some...questionable folks) but the rest of the square seems to be thriving with wonderful shops and restaurants. So many things are walking distance (the marsh, a ton of shops and restaurants, and even the HSU (it's still HSU to me) campus.

Stayed in October 2023

Nothing. Really - parking was confusing due to following day farmers market

Historic ambiance Location Adjoining restaurant very good

Stayed in July 2023

A bit noisy at night.

The location is great, right on the Arcata Plaza with nearby restaurants. I enjoyed the Farmer's Market on Saturday morning. There seem to be fewer homeless people on the Plaza than in previous visits.

Stayed in July 2023