The 5 Best Hotels in New Shoreham

#1 of 10 hotels in New Shoreham

• “I can finally answer the question: “Where’s your most favorite place you’ve ever stayed?””
• “Quaint place, lovely grounds and an innkeeper who loves his inn and the island.”
• “We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at his beautiful & quiet inn.”
• See more reviews of Old Town Inn

#2 of 10 hotels in New Shoreham

• “Nice place, bad mattress”
• “The breakfast was just so-so.”
• “Overpriced tiny room that did NOT meet any expectations!!”
• See more reviews of Payne's Harbor View Inn

#3 of 10 hotels in New Shoreham

• “Highly recommend”
• “Spectacular get away!!”
• “Excellent location and quiet”
• See more reviews of Rose Farm Inn

#4 of 10 hotels in New Shoreham

• “That the doors were left open during the day, hard to get...”
• “Great place to stay on Block Island”
• “Best time ever with good friends”
• See more reviews of National Hotel

#5 of 10 hotels in New Shoreham

• “Sabrina was absolutely amazing! Such a perfect hostess! She made us feel right at home and was willing to answer any q”
• “Will def go back!”
• “The Smell of fresh pastry woke me up in the morning.”
• See more reviews of Avonlea